Review for A. Manette Ansay’s “Vinegar Hill” (1994)
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
I am going to start this review by saying that the fact that “Vinegar Hill” was an Oprah’s Book Club pick didn’t deter me from reading it. I think a lot of people are passing up some great books because of the stigma of bad quality that surrounds her book club, even to this day. I’ve read several of her club offerings and found them to be hit or miss–much in the same fashion as any random book you’d find in literary fiction. Do people seriously expect EVERY book that Oprah recommends will be great? Perhaps, due to her larger than life persona, we expect too much of Oprah. Books are still a matter of personal preference, and Oprah’s tastes don’t always have to match mine. Lol, please…
Anyway, I actually really liked this book. A lot of reviewers use the words “bleak” and “depressing” to describe the tone of this book, and these words are very accurate. The story centers on Ellen and James, a married couple with two children, who fall on hard financial times and are forced to move in with James’ parents. Their home is a harsh, loveless place, where secrets are kept and Fritz (James’ father) rules through cruelty and intimidation. The whole time I read this I could feel the tension in the house building and building until Ellen makes a drastic choice and you’re able to find some sense of relief at the end.
I also thought Ms. Ansay did an excellent job with the setting of this book. Religion, specifically the family’s strict, traditional Catholic faith, also played an important role in this story. Back in 1972, people simply did not divorce. Women were responsible for maintaining their household, no matter how miserable they were and that was it. This book explores this dynamic, and it affected me deeply, even though some parts were tough to read. I’m glad the author made this a short book, if it were 50 pages longer I couldn’t see myself continuing to endure the character’s suffering.
3 thoughts on “Review: Vinegar Hill”
Thanks for the warning about Vinegar Hillbeing bleak and depressing. I just can’t do books like that anymore. While I regret that I’m probably missing out on a lot of great literature that way, ever since “Map of the World” — a relentlessly sad story — sent me into depression for a month, I’ve had to be careful. Coincidentally, when I did an Internet search of Map of the World just now, I noticed it, too, was an Oprah Book Club selection. I agree with you about that, by the way. Why dismiss a book just because it’s on a particular list?
I have “Map of the World” here at my house. I will read it someday, perhaps when I finish the big library stack I have here already! I find that with a lot of books, I’ll have every intention of reading it but then realize that I really can’t digest it emotionally. “The Lovely Bones” is such a book. I’ve tried multiple times and I can’t seem to get past page 40. *sigh*
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow, sounds like a really tough book. Like you say though, it was a reality at a certain period in time!